This is the heart of real Montauk. Food is good, the bar is the real thing and the crowd is reasonably tolerant of interlopers.
Perennial go-to late night spot. Hugely crowded in the summer so pretty unpleasant unless you are a horny 20 something. In that case the lines, overpriced drinks and crowding are totally worth it.
Hard core local Bonacker bar and a very welcome moderately priced restaurant in a great location.
Great for watching sports at the bar. Also it is the liveliest and coolest of a very few bars in East Hampton.
The slices are uniquely large and it is a cherished Columbia tradition. The pizza itself tho is not much better than in $1 slice places, so even though it is big, $4.50 is not that great of a value.
